Why SEO tools disagree on backlink counts

Published

No backlink tool sees the whole web, and each one counts differently. Two tools can report 40 and 120 referring domains for the same site on the same day, and both can be right by their own rules. The useful question isn't "which number is true" but "which links are real, and are they still there".

Five reasons the numbers differ

  1. Different crawlers. Each tool runs its own crawler, which visits different pages in a different order. Google's crawler sees far more than any of them.
  2. Different index sizes. A tool with a bigger index finds more of the small sites and deep pages that link out.
  3. Different update speeds. Tools recheck pages at different intervals, so one may still count a link that another has already seen removed. That matters for expired domains, whose links decay over time.
  4. Different counting rules. Is blog.example.com a separate referring domain from example.com? Some tools say yes, some count only the main domain. Are redirects, images and links in scripts counted?
  5. Different scores. "Domain Rating", "Domain Authority", "Trust Flow" and similar figures are each tool's own estimate, on its own scale. They aren't Google metrics and they don't convert into each other.

Which numbers to trust

How to compare domains fairly

  1. Use the same tool for every domain you're comparing.
  2. Note the date of the data.
  3. Open the five strongest linking pages for each domain and check the links are there.
  4. Look at what kind of sites link (news, universities, government, organisations) rather than the score.

How JuicyLeafs handles this

How we find and grade domains