Editorial links: what they are and why they're worth the most

Published

An editorial link is a link someone chose to give, because the page it points to was worth citing. Nobody paid for it, swapped it or added it themselves. A journalist linking to a study, a university library listing a useful resource, a government page pointing to a charity: those are editorial links, and they are the kind search engines trust most.

What makes a link editorial

Google's own spam policies describe the opposite: links that weren't "editorially placed or vouched for by the site's owner". So the test is simple to state: did an independent person decide this link belonged here? In practice, look for four things:

  1. Someone else controls the page. The linking site belongs to a different organisation from the one being linked.
  2. The link sits in the content. It's in the body of an article, guide or resource list, not in a footer, sidebar, comment or user profile.
  3. It's there for the reader. The surrounding text explains why the reader should follow it: a source, an example, a recommendation.
  4. Nothing was exchanged. No payment, no "you link to me, I link to you", no free product in return for a link.

Editorial links compared with other links

LinkWho placed itWhat search engines make of it
Editorial: a news article citing a sourceAn independent writer or editorStrong, trusted
Resource list on a university or government siteThe site's own staffStrong if the list is curated and kept up
Guest post written by the site being linked toThe person who benefitsWeak; often marked sponsored
Paid link or "sponsored post"Whoever paidShould be marked sponsored; unmarked, it breaks Google's rules
Directory, profile, forum or comment linkAnyoneLittle or none; usually nofollow
Link from a private blog networkThe network ownerTreated as spam

Why editorial links are worth the most

How people earn editorial links

The usual way is slow, real work: original research or data journalists want to cite, a free tool or resource people recommend, expert comment for the press, a project worth covering. "Editorial link building" services promise the same result faster; check exactly what they do. If they pay sites to place links, the links aren't editorial, whatever the invoice calls them.

The shortcut: domains that already have them

When an organisation closes, a project ends or a domain is simply forgotten, the domain lapses. The articles, reading lists and public pages that cited it usually stay online. Those editorial links now point to a domain nobody owns. Registering that domain, and building something on the same subject that deserves the links, is one of the few legitimate ways to start a site with editorial links already in place.

That's what JuicyLeafs looks for. Every domain in the catalogue was found through editorial links from news, university, government and other well-known sites, and the links are checked before the domain is listed. Two cautions apply:

How to tell whether a domain's links are editorial

  1. Open a sample of the linking pages and look at where the link sits: in the text, or in a sidebar, footer or comment?
  2. Read the sentence around it. Does it recommend or cite the site?
  3. Check who owns the linking site, and whether it's a real organisation with its own audience.
  4. Count the referring domains, not the links. Ten different news sites once each beat one site linking a thousand times.
  5. Look at the anchors. Editorial anchors are usually the name of the site or a plain description, not a commercial keyword.

Browse domains linked from news sites