Editorial links: what they are and why they're worth the most
An editorial link is a link someone chose to give, because the page it points to was worth citing. Nobody paid for it, swapped it or added it themselves. A journalist linking to a study, a university library listing a useful resource, a government page pointing to a charity: those are editorial links, and they are the kind search engines trust most.
What makes a link editorial
Google's own spam policies describe the opposite: links that weren't "editorially placed or vouched for by the site's owner". So the test is simple to state: did an independent person decide this link belonged here? In practice, look for four things:
- Someone else controls the page. The linking site belongs to a different organisation from the one being linked.
- The link sits in the content. It's in the body of an article, guide or resource list, not in a footer, sidebar, comment or user profile.
- It's there for the reader. The surrounding text explains why the reader should follow it: a source, an example, a recommendation.
- Nothing was exchanged. No payment, no "you link to me, I link to you", no free product in return for a link.
Editorial links compared with other links
| Link | Who placed it | What search engines make of it |
|---|---|---|
| Editorial: a news article citing a source | An independent writer or editor | Strong, trusted |
| Resource list on a university or government site | The site's own staff | Strong if the list is curated and kept up |
| Guest post written by the site being linked to | The person who benefits | Weak; often marked sponsored |
| Paid link or "sponsored post" | Whoever paid | Should be marked sponsored; unmarked, it breaks Google's rules |
| Directory, profile, forum or comment link | Anyone | Little or none; usually nofollow |
| Link from a private blog network | The network owner | Treated as spam |
Why editorial links are worth the most
- They're hard to fake. You can buy a guest post on almost any site. You can't buy a link in a BBC article, a university library guide or a government report. Search engines know that, so these links carry the most weight.
- They come from trusted sites. The places that give editorial links (news outlets, universities, public bodies, respected organisations) are themselves the most-cited sites on the web. Their trust passes along the link.
- They bring the right visitors. A link in a relevant article is clicked by people interested in the subject, long after the article is published.
- They last. News archives, academic pages and public records tend to stay online for years, so their links decay more slowly than links on blogs and directories. See link decay.
How people earn editorial links
The usual way is slow, real work: original research or data journalists want to cite, a free tool or resource people recommend, expert comment for the press, a project worth covering. "Editorial link building" services promise the same result faster; check exactly what they do. If they pay sites to place links, the links aren't editorial, whatever the invoice calls them.
The shortcut: domains that already have them
When an organisation closes, a project ends or a domain is simply forgotten, the domain lapses. The articles, reading lists and public pages that cited it usually stay online. Those editorial links now point to a domain nobody owns. Registering that domain, and building something on the same subject that deserves the links, is one of the few legitimate ways to start a site with editorial links already in place.
That's what JuicyLeafs looks for. Every domain in the catalogue was found through editorial links from news, university, government and other well-known sites, and the links are checked before the domain is listed. Two cautions apply:
- Stay on topic. Use the domain for something those linking pages would still be happy to cite. Turning it into something unrelated is what Google calls expired domain abuse.
- Check the links are still there. Pages move. JuicyLeafs rechecks the links when you reveal a domain, and the report names the linking sites.
How to tell whether a domain's links are editorial
- Open a sample of the linking pages and look at where the link sits: in the text, or in a sidebar, footer or comment?
- Read the sentence around it. Does it recommend or cite the site?
- Check who owns the linking site, and whether it's a real organisation with its own audience.
- Count the referring domains, not the links. Ten different news sites once each beat one site linking a thousand times.
- Look at the anchors. Editorial anchors are usually the name of the site or a plain description, not a commercial keyword.