Toxic backlinks and spam score: what to check before you buy a domain
A "toxic" backlink is a link from a spammy, hacked or link-selling site, and a spam score is a tool's estimate of how much a domain looks like sites that were penalised. Every domain has a few bad links, and Google mostly ignores them. What matters when you buy a domain is whether bad links make up the bulk of its profile, because then there's nothing good left to build on.
What Google actually says
- "Toxic links" isn't Google's term. It comes from SEO tools. Google's position is that its systems recognise most spammy links and simply give them no value, rather than counting them against you.
- Penalties are for link schemes. Google takes action against a site that buys links, sells them or is built to manipulate rankings, usually through a manual action, or by quietly discounting all of its links.
- The disavow tool is for exceptions. Google says most sites never need it. It's meant for sites with many paid or manipulative links, especially after a manual action.
So for an existing site, a handful of junk links is noise. For an expired domain it's different: you're buying the links, so you want them to be good ones.
What a spam score is
Several SEO tools publish a spam score, usually as a percentage. They compare a domain with thousands of domains that were penalised or banned and count shared traits: thin content, few pages, odd link patterns, links mostly from low-quality sites, and so on. A high score means "looks like sites that got into trouble", not "is in trouble". Treat it as a reason to look closer, then check the links themselves.
Spam scores also have blind spots on expired domains: a domain that has had no website for a year can look "thin" and score high even though its links are fine. Another tool may score the same domain quite differently.
Signs a domain has a bad link profile
| Sign | What it usually means |
|---|---|
| Most anchors are commercial keywords ("best payday loans") | Links were bought or built, not earned |
| Hundreds of linking sites on a few IP ranges | One owner's network: a PBN or link farm |
| Links from sites in unrelated languages or about casinos, pills or adult content | Spam campaigns or a hacked past |
| Thousands of links from comments, forums, profiles and directories | Automated link building |
| A sudden spike of new links, then nothing | A bought package |
| Archived pages show spam, a casino or pharmacy site, or another language | A previous owner already misused it |
| The domain is on email or security blacklists | Spam or malware was sent from it |
How to check a domain yourself
- Look at the referring domains, not the total links. Open a sample of the biggest ones. Are they real sites with their own readers? See how to check the backlinks of any domain.
- Read the anchors. A natural profile is mostly the domain's name, its URL and plain phrases.
- Check where the links sit. In the text of articles, or in footers, sidebars and comments?
- Look at the domain's past. Archived pages show what it hosted. See how to check a domain's history.
- Search for it. Search
site:the domain and its name in quotes to see what's indexed and what people said about it. - Check blacklists if you plan to send email from the domain.
When to walk away, and when not to
Walk away when the good links are a small minority, when the anchors are mostly commercial, or when the domain's own past shows spam. You'd be buying a cleanup job.
Don't worry about a scattering of scraper sites, link directories and foreign-language copies on an otherwise solid profile. Every popular domain collects them. Google ignores them, and so should you.
If you've already bought a domain with a few clearly paid links, you can list them in a disavow file. Only bother if there are many, or if Search Console shows a manual action.
How JuicyLeafs screens for spam
Before a domain is listed, its links are screened automatically: links from link farms and a high spam score lower the grade or rule the domain out, and names about adult, gambling or pharmacy subjects aren't listed at all. Each listing shows its spam score, and the report you get on reveal names the linking sites so you can check them yourself. The methodology has the details.